Little Anthony’s Pizza: Your Go-To Spot for Authentic Pizza in New Castle, DE

I grew up in the area, so when I used to work at the Rita’s right in the plaza, that used to be my favorite lunch spot. The cheddar broccoli bites are my favorite!!! I walked in and asked the guy how long, he said 5 mins, and that’s exactly how long it took. He was very generous, as he always has been. The prices have went up (High as hell), but it’s worth it when you have good customer service to go along with it. Would definitely recommend.

There are no words to describe the taste of the food at this restaurant. Everything is delicious . My family and I love this place, and the people are so friendly. God bless these guys!

​Style and Quality: The pizza is the main draw, with many customers calling it the "best pizza in Delaware" and a "real deal" New York-style pie. Reviewers consistently praise the quality and flavor. ​Crust: It is often described as having a thin, foldable, and perfectly crispy crust. The Sicilian pizza, specifically, is noted for its excellent crunchy crust. ​Sauce & Cheese: The ingredients are generally considered fresh and delicious. Some enthusiasts in specialized reviews mention that the sauce can be mellow and the pizza can be a bit heavy on the cheese and grease, suggesting that asking for it "well done" can help manage the crispness. Vibe: Little Anthony's has a distinctly nostalgic, vintage, or retro feel, with a casual and cozy atmosphere. The dining area is clean, and the location is noted for having a kids' playground in the community plaza. ​Staff & Service: The staff is consistently described as friendly, welcoming, and attentive, often treating patrons like family. This high-quality customer service is a significant factor in the positive reviews.

There's an overwhelming sense of nostalgia coming here. From the atmosphere to the pizza, it feels like they haven't changed a thing in 30 years. The pizza is thin, foldable and perfect. The back of the shop has a quaint place to sit and eat at red-top tables with fans overhead. The front has numerous drink fridges with a ton of options. The menu overhead has moveable letters and very reasonable prices. Staff was hospitable and seems to treat regulars as family. It's very easy to eat at least 4 slices of a large pie yourself (if not more). This spot came highly reccomended by our friends and we can now see why. It looks like we will be making the 18 minute drive frequently now. Delicious!

The service is quick and friendly! The pizza is so good and tastes fresh, NY style pizza. The cheesesteaks are average, the roll is the best part of it. Would skip the cheesesteak next time!

This place has some of the best cheesesteaks in the area. I've been going here for 15 years. Same people working there the whole time.

Little Anthony’s is hands down my favorite place in New Castle for pizza and cheesesteaks. It reminds me of the real neighborhood pizza shops from my childhood — that classic taste and vibe you don’t find everywhere anymore. Consistently great food and a place I genuinely love. 6 stars!

Little Anthony’s Pizzeria has become one of my go‑to spots, and honestly, it’s because they get everything right. Every time I walk in, I’m greeted like family — warm, friendly, and genuinely happy to see you. That alone keeps me coming back, but the food seals the deal. Of course, their pizza is always amazing but their menu goes way beyond that. Their pasta dishes are comforting and full of flavor, the salads are always fresh and satisfying, and the desserts never disappoint. And I have to mention the cheesesteaks… they’re seriously some of the best around. Juicy, flavorful, and made with the same care they put into everything else. Whether I’m grabbing something quick or sitting down to enjoy your meal, the service is consistently kind and attentive. You can tell they take pride in what they do, and it shows in every bite. Little Anthony’s is one of those places that just makes you feel good — great food, great people, and a welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend